Season 7 Final: David Archuleta vs. David Cook

May 19th, 2008

So, it's boiled down to the American Idol final that everybody was predicting: David against David! Syesha Mercado had a good run, making it all the way down to the top three contestants, but everybody always knew if she was in with a chance of the final, then it was a slim chance at best.

So, let's recap a little about the two finalists, before making our prediction of who is going to be the American Idol winner:

David Archuleta

17-year old David Archuleta is from Murray, UT and nearly never made it to American Idol due to paralysed vocal chords in his youth which could have stopped him from singing altogether. However, he overcame this, and in style too, with an outstanding run of great performances on the show. Stand out performance for AIF? "The long and winding road"...

Best comments of the competition: "You crushed the competition." (Simon about his 'Love me Tender' performance)

Worst comments of the competition: "That was a mess." (Simon, on his rendition of 'We Can Work it Out')



David Cook

David Cooks hails from Blue Springs, MO and has brought the 'rockier' element to the fore again, in a similar way to Chris Daughtry. Whether things will go the same way for him as they did fo"r Chris (i.e. second place, but then faaaaarrr more successful in his musical career than the winner) remains to be seen, but he has definitely come in to form at the right time.

Best comments: "David Cook wins the night." (Simon on the pre-final performance of 'I Don't Want to Miss a Thing')

Worst comments: "Just above average." (Simon, again, on his performance of 'I'm Alive')

So, who do we think will be the 2008 American Idol Winner? Whether it's the right result or not, we expect Mr Archuleta to walk away with the crown (the granny vote will carry it...)

Entry Filed under: Winners, David Archuleta, David Cook

6 Comments Add your own

  • 1. Sacramento Weddings  |  May 19th, 2008 at 2:56 pm

    Its not just the Granny vote that supports the Younger David:

    1) there are the “Fantards” — tweens & pre-teens who populate the AI boards

    2) there are the Vote For The Worst folks and Howard Stern listeners.

    because of the broad spectrum of support (both good & bad), The Archulator will win by a “GASP”

  • 2. Jane  |  May 21st, 2008 at 3:26 am

    Archuleta out sang Cook and will probable win. Cook had the lead coming into the competition tonight. He just did not let go and let loose. SAD! He had such great potential.

  • 3. are why eh en  |  May 21st, 2008 at 6:11 am

    David Cook not only deserves this more, but would be more successful. Simon said so himself on Leno..

    Young David has a great voice, but who wants to go to a concert and see a young kid sing old songs? American Idol is made to produce a star that will be a music icon for the younger generation, and I do not believe that young David can do that with his music style of choice. I am 21 and I can not stand to listen to young Davis sing; it bores the hell out of me. So David Cook, the best of luck to you, save us all….

  • 4. LouieJay1987  |  May 21st, 2008 at 5:03 pm

    I hope David Cook will win the title tomorow cuz he is very talented guy! he can arrange any type of song into his vibe and he gots all Idol package ill go with DC !!

  • 5. LouieJay1987  |  May 21st, 2008 at 5:14 pm

    I just watch again the Idol reply on cable,and! i must say that two David’s had a good fight! im a follower of Idol since Season 3 and i love! this season even though my kababayan Ramiele Malubay out early on top9 round like Camile Velasco in Season3. I still like this season lots of best talents this year than other past season’! AI Season7 R0cks!!! -louie frm. philippines

  • 6. LouieJay1987  |  May 21st, 2008 at 5:21 pm

    I just watch again the Idol reply on cable awhile ago,and! i must say that two David’s had a good fight! im a follower of Idol since Season 3 and i love! this season even though my kababayan Ramiele Malubay out early on top9 round like Camile Velasco in Season3. I still like this season lots of best talents this year than other past season’! AI Season7 R0cks!!! -louie frm. philippines

Leave a Comment

Required

Required, hidden

Some HTML allowed:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>

Trackback this post  |  Subscribe to the comments via RSS Feed


Disclaimer

This site is for the fans, and is 100% un-official. We are not affiliated with official show site in any way, but simply aim to give you a shared perspective of the show from the fans point of view. All Trademarks and Copyrights are property of the original holder.

About AIF.com

This one is for all of the fans! Those of us who can't wait for the next show the minute after one has finished. For everyone who has ever cried, laughed out loud or shouted at their TV set while watching the show...

We feature the most comprehensive collection of Idol resources on the Internet: sections dedicated contestants, past winners, photos, downloads, videos, gossip, the auditions themselves and of course the judges!

You can also fully participate in any of our threads simply by adding your own comments - please do, we love to hear what our readers have to say!

Ours is a truly global fan site; whether you are American, or watching the show in the UK, elsewhere in Europe or indeed anywhere else in the world, we are here for you! Please do keep your comments in English though, that way we can all read what you're saying...

Show Times

Never miss a show with our schedule..
Saturday

Most Recent Posts

Categories

Links

Feeds

Calendar

November 2008
M T W T F S S
« Oct    
 12
3456789
10111213141516
17181920212223
24252627282930